WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #241

Clay Aiken - Measure of a Man

#241 · Feb 24, 2026 · 1h 45m

Clay Aiken - Measure of a Man

This week it's Measure of a Man, Clay Aiken's 2003 debut after American Idol, a record with 42 musicians, 11 producers and a crowd of songwriters. Garrett stitched it into a concept album about a man we call The Claiken, and nobody told Clay what Solitaire is about. We both hate it.

Did you hate it?

Clay Aiken - Measure of a Man

The moments

  1. Tim's sabbatical in Sedona, the interns' Jagerbomb fountain
  2. You don't build a skull throne without collecting skulls
  3. Garrett watched a whole season of Idol from the bath
  4. He saw the card before Seacrest read it
  5. The Amazing Race watermelon slingshot
  6. Every catchphrase we've got, plus Tubthumping
  7. Give him a soul patch and he's Chris Gaines' son
  8. Could Tim lose a fight to Clay Aiken?
  9. Garrett's track by track concept album
  10. Tim gets out the whiteboard for invisible DNA
  11. Ruining a life by trebuchet
  12. Tim's brave face, scary face and friendly face
  13. Solitaire is not about cards
  14. Kenny Rogers should mail this guy a rhino turd

Said on the show

Listen, man, I can't explain it. I'm not here to justify any of the things I'm saying. I'm just here to report what I did.

Garrett · 6:44

Thorough and showmanship wise, it's the most animated and articulate I've seen you in eight years.

Garrett · 42:17

It's a classy song about being a chronic masturbator.

1:23:15

This is music for people that don't like music.

Tim · 1:41:53

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.