The moments
- Tim's sabbatical in Sedona, the interns' Jagerbomb fountain
- You don't build a skull throne without collecting skulls
- Garrett watched a whole season of Idol from the bath
- He saw the card before Seacrest read it
- The Amazing Race watermelon slingshot
- Every catchphrase we've got, plus Tubthumping
- Give him a soul patch and he's Chris Gaines' son
- Could Tim lose a fight to Clay Aiken?
- Garrett's track by track concept album
- Tim gets out the whiteboard for invisible DNA
- Ruining a life by trebuchet
- Tim's brave face, scary face and friendly face
- Solitaire is not about cards
- Kenny Rogers should mail this guy a rhino turd
Said on the show
Listen, man, I can't explain it. I'm not here to justify any of the things I'm saying. I'm just here to report what I did.
Garrett · 6:44
Thorough and showmanship wise, it's the most animated and articulate I've seen you in eight years.
Garrett · 42:17
It's a classy song about being a chronic masturbator.
1:23:15
This is music for people that don't like music.
Tim · 1:41:53
Running bits
Garrett's high school poetrysince #1 · 2018
Any lyric bad enough gets compared to the sad boy poems Garrett wrote at 16.
Where it started#1 · Korn - Follow the LeaderJan 22, 2018 · at 15:05
The weekly 9-11 referencesince #5 · 2018
There is a 9-11 reference in more episodes than you would think. Since mid-2021 we call it out when it lands: your weekly 9-11 reference.
Where it started#5 · Smash Mouth - Astro LoungeFeb 19, 2018 · at 4:11
La Fin. Shia LaBeouf.since #152 · 2022
How Tim closes out the history segment.
Where it started#152 · Hootie & the Blowfish - Cracked Rear ViewMay 31, 2022 · at 16:20
Go Wildcatssince PRE #95 · 2023
Every high school and college in an artist's history gets a Go Wildcats, whatever the mascot.
Where it startedPRE #95 · Harvey Danger - Flagpole SittaSep 26, 2023 · at 9:54
Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.