WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #247

Theory of a Deadman - Scars & Souvenirs

#247 · Jun 16, 2026 · 1h 54m

Theory of a Deadman - Scars & Souvenirs

A listener suggested Theory of a Deadman's Scars & Souvenirs, so we gave it two whole weeks. It's Nickelback-adjacent butt rock drifting toward bro country, sung by a man with a list of complaints about every woman he's met, and somewhere in there Boy Power International held its first meeting. Tim hated it from the top, and Garrett held out until the very end before admitting he does too.

Did you hate it?

Theory of a Deadman - Scars & Souvenirs

The moments

  1. Gino turns the dial from courteous to hostile
  2. Fifty cent cheeseburgers before Spider-Man
  3. WWE Hell in the Sack
  4. Theory covers the Allman Brothers
  5. She's a professional slip and fall grifter
  6. The first meeting of Boy Power
  7. A fun road trip, definitely not fleeing the mob
  8. The secret Patreon goal
  9. Your face tattooed on your face, one inch left
  10. A Lovecraftian Cyrano de Bergerac
  11. A date should end with a firm handshake
  12. Hold on, like Taco Bell
  13. Whose baby is in the backseat?
  14. Matty B's Googly-Eyed Clams

Said on the show

This is the soul patch of music.

Tim · 17:39

Interpretation is by no means acceptance. That's written on the wall outside of the boys' club.

36:36

God, we were not focused on the right thing in 2008. I would have started a Canadian butt rock band, is what I'm saying.

1:44:48

It's so much more listenable than a lot of music. But I do hate it.

Garrett · 1:51:13

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.