WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

From listeners

WHAT YOU SAID

Reviews, emails and posts you wrote somewhere else that we liked enough to keep. The meaner the better, within reason. Want to end up here? Talk to Us.

28 Apple reviews calling Tim a sucker11 of them say nothing else27 clippings4.2 avg rating
  • Men love to hear themselves speak

    NUMBER ONE ANOOP FANApple Podcasts · Nov 2019★☆☆☆☆

  • The lil Wayne episode made me unsubscribe.

    N0t4g33kApple Podcasts · Mar 2019★☆☆☆☆

  • Ironically, I was about to do a show on these guys on a podcast I have called "Why I hate this podcast"

    AddictingTunesApple Podcasts · May 2020★☆☆☆☆

  • Two of the unfunniest guys I've ever heard spending an hour and a half taking about why a band isn't funny.

    @richardcoysYouTube · on #102 Bloodhound Gang

  • ok it's ok I like the idea but…U HATE MCR?!

    sleep girl 24Apple Podcasts · May 2024★★★☆☆

  • This is a maddening spectacle of lovecraftian proportions. 2/10. Would not DUH again

    @daishoryujin95YouTube · on #53 Corey Feldman

  • This duo absolutely ripped apart one of my favorite albums in a way I almost entirely disagreed with. But it was hilariously funny.

    Momo.198Apple Podcasts · Apr 2021★★★★☆

  • Their jokes are too repetitive and their first names make no sense. Their research gets a B minus and the cover bands are the best. ... Could somebody bring me a cheeseburger.

    Keith in IowaApple Podcasts · Apr 2021★★★★★

  • These guys are very funny. I especially like when they talk about music I know. But then it's usually them being mean about music I like? And I would never discover any music through this. But it's still good

    JayEmm95Apple Podcasts · Nov 2022★★★★★

  • Love everything about this show except the improv, the cowboy talk, the high school poetry, the IUC, and I'm almost certain this is just one guy using 2 voices poorly. Other than that. Everything else is great.

    Batnest2Apple Podcasts · Jan 2023★★★★★

  • I love this podcast but I still can't tell their voices apart. Whichever one is Tim is a sucker

    BillSheridanApple Podcasts · Jun 2018★★★★★

  • Tim is one of thd most infuriating people on earth and that is why he's so good at this.

    @daishoryujin95YouTube · on #127 NOFX

  • I love you guys, I swear. But. It's 'cast aspersions' not 'cast dispersions'.

    SouljakkerApple Podcasts · Dec 2018★★★★★

  • How is it possible you can do a weezer podcast and deny they have a cruise. ... All Gino had to do was go on Weezerpedia. Get your facts straight boys. Five stars.

    Lucky.LeckieApple Podcasts · Feb 2019★★★★★

  • The best source of info ANYWHERE about the Dutch Megacharts. My only complaint? Some episodes fail to mention anything about the Dutch Megacharts, but I'm going to go ahead and blame Brad for that oversight.

    Salocin NApple Podcasts · Jan 2019★★★★★

  • I hate that I love this podcast. ...especially when it's about an album or artist I love. It's fun and ridiculous, not mean or snarky.

    Lea-beanApple Podcasts · May 2023★★★★★

  • This podcast is so funny, the murderer hiding in the backseat of my car gave himself away because he couldn't hold in his laughter. I owe Gary and Tom my life. Can't recommend enough.

    Apple reviewerApple Podcasts · Jul 2020★★★★★

  • I am a bartender and one of the joys of my job is torturing my customers through our jukebox. This podcast has been a wonderful tool for picking out new songs. That Hootie and the Blowfish week was ROUGH for them.

    ArianaApple Podcasts · Dec 2022★★★★★

  • excruciatingly funny music discourse marinated in the shameful brine of my nü metal teenage years.

    Hilary T.Facebook · Sep 2018

  • Their catty banter, their continual hatred of everything, it's all my black cold heart needs. five out of five stars.

    Deanna W.Facebook

  • I'll definitely be recommending the podcast to my best friends and the weekly albums to my worst foes.

    Pants123kkApple Podcasts · May 2019★★★★★

  • Here's your 5 star review, now do Lupe Fiasco's Lasers you cowards.

    Michael the lasers email guyApple Podcasts · Dec 2023★★★★★

  • Tim says "absolutely" 18 times this episode. Garrett says "Interesting" 9 times.

    @realgar286YouTube · on #233 Live

  • Twenty One Pilots is my favorite band and Ironically I really liked how you crucified Vessel. You made me appreciate them more.

    @isa8555YouTube · on #163 Blurryface

  • I always thought that this podcast was extremely popular ... I have been further validated by being acknowledged as one of the only 8 other people that listen to the very end of the show.

    @milobradburyYouTube · on #167 2022 Year in Review

  • The driver at the stoplight next to you sees nothing but a madman laughing maniacally through the window, but you know everything is alright.

    The.ALienApple Podcasts · Jul 2024★★★★★

  • Wonderful atmosphere! Great food! Excellent service! Staff even sang happy birthday to my son! Will be returning! #stillwanttimantwoord

    Austin C.Facebook · Aug 2018