WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #5

Smash Mouth - Astro Lounge

#5 · Feb 19, 2018 · 1h 12m

Smash Mouth - Astro Lounge

Tim half-suggested Smash Mouth's Astro Lounge, and Garrett found out he not only owned it but knew every word, the soundtrack of a 16-year-old Garrett cruising for ladies in 1999. It's dumbly positive nine-genres-at-once pop that sounds composed by a computer, with whistling nobody asked for. We both hate it, and Garrett hates himself for how much he loved it.

Did you hate it?

Smash Mouth - Astro Lounge

The moments

  1. Tim has an unpopular opinion: this record is bad
  2. Garrett owned this and knows every word
  3. It's the soundtrack of Garrett's summer of 99
  4. Nine genres at once in every song
  5. Oppressive, upbeat and dumbly positive
  6. It looks like somebody got their first Mac
  7. Garrett knew all these songs, and Tim is disappointed
  8. How many times Garrett heard this at 16
  9. A song written from fortune cookies
  10. The whistling
  11. A karaoke guy adds a clothespin for every the
  12. This could be a Beck song if not so loud
  13. Every teen movie is the same movie
  14. I hate it more than before

Said on the show

Tim, not only do I hate this album, I hate myself for loving this album when it first came out.

Garrett · 1:50

It is oppressive. It is upbeat. It's dumbly positive. The whole thing sounds like it was composed by a computer.

3:00

I hate it more than when we started. I hate myself for liking it as much as I did.

1:10:26

Running bits

  • The weekly 9-11 referenceStarted here

    There is a 9-11 reference in more episodes than you would think. Since mid-2021 we call it out when it lands: your weekly 9-11 reference.

    In this episode at

    Comes up in 134 episodes · See every one →

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.