The moments
- Garrett's one armed violence job
- We choose to believe their dad handled snakes
- So your brother plays drums? No. Also, he's 14.
- One of them is a sexy McPoyle
- Future intern Tom B. Rady
- The time Tim testified against Garrett at the Hague
- U2 asked us to tour. Tim said no.
- Vomit, beer, three more songs
- Bathing in milk like the McPoyles
- Airbrushed into a PS2 game cover
- Jesus is Dracula
- Sex on Fire is about an Orwellian nanny state
- 17 sounds like a Kohl's Christmas ad
- Cleaning and lovemaking both kick up dust
Said on the show
Yes, yes, I do, Garrett. This album pisses me off.
Tim · 1:52
It's been a minute since we've had something that just really earned the hate moniker. And I want to stress that, Timmy. It earned it.
Garrett · 2:12
By the time you're done with it, it looks like a PS2 video game cover.
29:38
I liked their old music before they were popular, but again, to be clear, not because they got popular. I dislike this album because this album sucks.
Tim · 1:27:12
Running bits
Garrett's high school poetrysince #1 · 2018
Any lyric bad enough gets compared to the sad boy poems Garrett wrote at 16.
Where it started#1 · Korn - Follow the LeaderJan 22, 2018 · at 15:05
The ApologetiX coversince #95 · 2020
A Christian parody band with 35 albums of cleaned up covers. If they covered the song, we play it.
Where it started#95 · Good Charlotte - The Young and the HopelessJun 16, 2020 · at 39:09
Go Wildcatssince PRE #95 · 2023
Every high school and college in an artist's history gets a Go Wildcats, whatever the mascot.
Where it startedPRE #95 · Harvey Danger - Flagpole SittaSep 26, 2023 · at 9:54
Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.