WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #231

Kings of Leon - Only By The Night

#231 · Aug 19, 2025 · 1h 33m

Kings of Leon - Only By The Night

We both own the first Kings of Leon albums and have seen them live, so we came into Only By the Night with some goodwill. It didn't last: this is the record where the weird Southern garage band got airbrushed into arena rock with reverb on everything. It's been a minute since an album truly earned it, and this one did. We both hate it.

Did you hate it?

Kings of Leon - Only By The Night

The moments

  1. Garrett's one armed violence job
  2. We choose to believe their dad handled snakes
  3. So your brother plays drums? No. Also, he's 14.
  4. One of them is a sexy McPoyle
  5. Future intern Tom B. Rady
  6. The time Tim testified against Garrett at the Hague
  7. U2 asked us to tour. Tim said no.
  8. Vomit, beer, three more songs
  9. Bathing in milk like the McPoyles
  10. Airbrushed into a PS2 game cover
  11. Jesus is Dracula
  12. Sex on Fire is about an Orwellian nanny state
  13. 17 sounds like a Kohl's Christmas ad
  14. Cleaning and lovemaking both kick up dust

Said on the show

Yes, yes, I do, Garrett. This album pisses me off.

Tim · 1:52

It's been a minute since we've had something that just really earned the hate moniker. And I want to stress that, Timmy. It earned it.

Garrett · 2:12

By the time you're done with it, it looks like a PS2 video game cover.

29:38

I liked their old music before they were popular, but again, to be clear, not because they got popular. I dislike this album because this album sucks.

Tim · 1:27:12

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.