WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #223

Alien Ant Farm - ANThology

#223 · Mar 25, 2025 · 1h 31m

Alien Ant Farm - ANThology

We spent a week with Alien Ant Farm's ANThology to answer one question: does this band have any other songs besides the Smooth Criminal cover? Technically yes, and the cover is still by far the best thing on it. Tim hates the rest of this unremarkable album, Garrett only mehs it, and we filled the gaps by turning half the tracklist into a saga about giant alien ants conquering Earth.

Did you hate it?

Alien Ant Farm - ANThology

The moments

  1. Searching for the sexy in Sexy Spring
  2. Garrett begs you to stop listening
  3. The Null, an afterlife run by giant ants
  4. The Papa Roach blood oath
  5. Michael Jackson's prank calls to Russell Crowe
  6. The I thought it was piss defense
  7. Courage is about an alien getting catfished
  8. To Catch a Predator, but he's a giant ant
  9. Two alien conquerors with a failing marriage
  10. If every shot is a Dutch angle, none of them are
  11. Alien Jesus with drawn on abs
  12. The same lyric, two songs in a row
  13. What's a succotash wish?
  14. Tim in a human sized Crown Royal bag

Said on the show

The problem is it's so bland. I think I maybe meh it more than I hate it.

Tim · 2:15

I can say at the onset, I hated doing this for the show.

Garrett · 3:02

I don't have a human penis.

32:16

No, I don't hate it. I meh it, which I think is actually a promotion from the start of the show.

Garrett · 1:27:22

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.