WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #246

Lindsay Lohan - Speak

#246 · May 26, 2026 · 1h 39m

Lindsay Lohan - Speak

We spent a week with Speak, the 2004 album Lindsay Lohan released at the peak of Mean Girls. It sounds like 49 people and a lot of suits made it, she has sung in public about 15 times, and somewhere around track two it turns into Misery. We both hated it from the jump, and we still have a Johnny Cash style comeback album in mind for her.

Did you hate it?

Lindsay Lohan - Speak

The moments

  1. Please stop stalking us
  2. Tim's paparazzo years and his crooked nose
  3. Tim, self-declared Herbie expert
  4. Garrett's real birth name
  5. Nobody stayed for the Club Dread Q&A
  6. Leathery but also papery
  7. She has sung in public exactly 15 times
  8. Lindsay's gritty late-era Johnny Cash album
  9. Tom B. Brady's cheekbones
  10. Accidentally a Misery concept album
  11. Do you have cold cuts? I need a macaw
  12. A one night stand with a ghost
  13. Steve?
  14. People with pants full of snakes

Said on the show

Audience, you have to stop stalking us.

Tim · 0:40

It's 25 years before AI, but it feels like AI slop.

46:33

I'm going to be honest, Garrett, I'm in love with the idea of this life with Derek.

Tim · 1:22:51

When I sit next to people on the plane, I pay a lot of attention to their laps.

Garrett · 1:26:50

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.