WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / PRE #132

Vertical Horizon - Everything You Want

PRE #132 · Aug 26, 2025 · 1h 18m

Vertical Horizon - Everything You Want

This week we went back to 1999 for Vertical Horizon's Everything You Want, the softest of soft rock and a love song to the friend zone. Tim calls it boring, flaccid and stupid, video included, and hates it. Garrett related to it a little too much in high school and doesn't hate it, though he concedes it makes you sad.

Did you hate it?

Vertical Horizon - Everything You Want

The moments

  1. Tim and the interns catch a vampire in the park
  2. Rabies is back on the podcast
  3. Teenage Garrett's two-year girlfriend heist
  4. What if a horizon was vertical?
  5. A very specific chin beard
  6. Drummer recruited by the singer's mom at Borders
  7. Richard Marx, airline hero, and the film No Stops
  8. Who rocks harder than Vertical Horizon?
  9. The song is a catfishing scheme
  10. The digital multi-peep
  11. Garrett Harvey is vomiting on the floor
  12. Two parallel timelines, four feet apart
  13. A listener's band stole our tag team name
  14. Tim interviewed fun. for the Huffington Post, allegedly

Said on the show

This band name implores you to never think about it.

9:34

Here's something you never want to say about a music video. Malcolm in the Middle did it better.

35:30

It's the greatest peep of all, Garrett.

Tim · 1:03:56

Stop struggling. Just breathe in that thick, thick candy. Tim, you are human quicksand.

Garrett · 1:09:22

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.