WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / PRE #141

Eagle Eye Cherry - Save Tonight

PRE #141 · Feb 10, 2026 · 57m

Eagle Eye Cherry - Save Tonight

Tim picked Eagle-Eye Cherry's Save Tonight, the 1997 one-hit wonder we both knew every word of without knowing who sang it. Neither of us hated it, top or bottom. We just don't think it's the romantic ditty everyone thinks it is: it's a man faking a prison sentence, or a space war, or a time loop, to get out of a relationship.

Did you hate it?

Eagle Eye Cherry - Save Tonight

The moments

  1. Tim lights an illegal fire barrel to set the mood
  2. The wrong way up an off-ramp to see Beck and Dylan
  3. Allen Ginsberg sings William Blake, for some reason
  4. Wikipedia's list of Deaths from Hepatitis
  5. We are the Eagle-Eye Cherry of podcasting
  6. Fred's tip: eat your ice cream shirtless
  7. Break up with her by faking a prison sentence
  8. Visit prisoners by saying you're their lawyer
  9. Save Tonight is a Groundhog Day situation
  10. A time loop where every day ends in Final Destination
  11. If you're holding a cleaver, go ahead and cleave
  12. Win any street fight by singing this, walking backward
  13. Gmail's AI summary of Arthur's kidnapping email
  14. Doc Martens should get to write a Metallica song

Said on the show

This guy, Garrett, is the musical equivalent of our podcast. Tiny bit of early success, still doing it, occasionally getting to be on TV or a movie.

Tim · 10:33

This is music designed to be sold in a Starbucks.

11:41

Listen, if you're already holding a cleaver, go ahead and cleave.

25:48

I don't think it's the romantic ditty that everyone seems to think it is.

Tim · 36:51

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.