WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / PRE #94

The All-American Rejects - Dirty Little Secret

PRE #94 · Aug 29, 2023 · 1h 13m

The All-American Rejects - Dirty Little Secret

This prepisode we spent a week with The All-American Rejects' Dirty Little Secret, a pop punk song the band insists is not based on real events. We have theories about who the secret really is, and we go through every confession card in the music video. Neither of us got there: it's dumb, catchy and just good enough.

Did you hate it?

The All-American Rejects - Dirty Little Secret

The moments

  1. 1:46Tim threatens to reveal Garrett's dirty secrets
  2. 2:28Tim, secret American Pie superfan
  3. 5:21An intern digging for food scraps finds the demo
  4. 6:51The Oklahoma paste
  5. 7:33Colin Powell on backing vocals
  6. 12:40Pitching American Empty Nesters
  7. 18:30Our theory: the songwriters are each other's secret
  8. 19:33A warm, linty block of cheddar in her pocket
  9. 20:42Uncle Windmill and reverse fly fishing
  10. 27:10Deli ham in Garrett's front pocket
  11. 31:37I pee in the sink: we need more information
  12. 34:28Literally afraid to take the next step
  13. 43:51Tim bought every CD single instead of the album
  14. 50:57Trapt's Chris Brown wants to fight behind the Applebee's

Said on the show

I'm going to reveal so many of Garrett's secrets.

Tim · 3:08

That's true, I have none. First draft, last draft, don't look back.

Garrett · 25:29

It's dumb. It's like super middle of the road.

Tim · 46:16

It's just good enough. It's catchy. It's kind of dumb. It's incriminating.

Garrett · 46:41

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.