WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #80

Green Day - American Idiot

#80 · Nov 26, 2019 · 1h 32m

Green Day - American Idiot

Our third week in a row of Billies brings us to American Idiot, Green Day's 2004 rock opera and eventual Broadway musical. We both hated it from the first question, and a week of St. Jimmy, Jesus of Suburbia and What's-Her-Name only convinced us it's one body with three personalities fighting for control. Just buy a Bad Religion album.

Did you hate it?

Green Day - American Idiot

The moments

  1. A correction: Green Day also had to credit David Bowie
  2. We could just skip to the end where we still hate it
  3. From General Apathy to Rage and Disgust in eight days
  4. We have written better concept albums, nay musicals
  5. A huge ripoff of Quadrophenia and Tommy
  6. A becoming, and then an unbecoming
  7. Dining with Dern
  8. Tim pays this song a compliment
  9. The worst suite Tim has ever heard, out of 17
  10. Fun fact: Tré Cool went to clown college
  11. Beck acquires a mariachi band in 15 minutes
  12. Beck lives behind our couch four months a year
  13. Just buy a Bad Religion album
  14. A six month Green Day retrospective, maybe

Said on the show

I do. I hate this album. This is terrible.

Tim · 1:12

God, we really could save everybody a lot of heartache and just skip to the end where we still hate it.

1:36

Garrett, this is the worst suite I've ever heard.

Tim · 1:12:21

It's musically better. It's written by intelligent people.

1:25:57

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.