WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #76

Ashlee Simpson - Autobiography

#76 · Oct 1, 2019 · 1h 27m

Ashlee Simpson - Autobiography

We dyed our hair black and spent the week with Autobiography, Ashlee Simpson's 2004 debut and the soundtrack to one very famous lip sync. It's a well-built pop album for its time, sung by someone still learning to sing, about an emotional huntress who would like to be an alley cat. It's room temperature, it's no Corey Feldman, and neither of us can hate it.

Did you hate it?

Ashlee Simpson - Autobiography

The moments

  1. Tim's dyed black hair
  2. Autobiography should have ended in two E's
  3. Tim's pilgrimage to her birthplace
  4. Garrett submitted a Christmas song to Disney
  5. The lip sync, and the strange little jig
  6. AshleeSimpson.com is a real goop
  7. She's an emotional huntress
  8. Not insane enough, not daring enough: room temperature
  9. One note off from a Modest Mouse song
  10. Picture this: cat play
  11. Look up Quicksandvids.com
  12. Tied to a chair like Michael Madsen in Reservoir Dogs
  13. Number one on the Billboard 200, triple platinum
  14. Thank God there was no Twitter at that age

Said on the show

I don't think so. It's too competent.

Garrett · 1:49

Nobody is saying anything interesting enough to be truly insane. And the music is not daring enough to falter and just be unlistenable. So it's just room temperature.

23:58

I think it actually is a really well-architected pop album for the time. Right. But doesn't make it good.

1:21:10

It's no Corey. It's no Slipknot.

Garrett · 1:22:31

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.