WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #74

Toby Keith - Shock'n Y'all

#74 · Sep 3, 2019 · 1h 23m

Toby Keith - Shock'n Y'all

Garrett picked Toby Keith's Shock'n Y'all to mark our all-important 74th album, a return visit after Unleashed. It's tamer on the surface and just as weird underneath, from I Love This Bar to the Taliban Song. Tim hated it from the start, and by the end Toby Keith pushed Garrett off the edge too.

Did you hate it?

Toby Keith - Shock'n Y'all

The moments

  1. Toby Keith moonlighting at an Oklahoma City Walmart
  2. Lucifer intercepts Toby's prayer
  3. Toby's career, mapped onto the rise of Hitler
  4. Does Toby Keith have a signature scent?
  5. The eight-shot Long Island in a mason jar
  6. I Love This Bar: a bar or a sex club?
  7. Garrett announces to the restaurant he's on a date
  8. The military is exclusively fighting giant wolves
  9. If Tim were Jesus: teach everyone about bacteria
  10. If Garrett were Jesus: enemies get venomous snake arms
  11. Time for Me to Ride is secretly War Pigs
  12. Sending Gino undercover as a sexy lady
  13. Mistaking the Taliban Song for a song about humanity
  14. Toby's beast is named the Grim Creeper

Said on the show

Yes, but I do hate it less than the Sublime pick.

Tim · 2:01

For the sake of the episode, let me begin just shy, just standing on the shores of Lake Hate, looking out and thinking about dipping a toe.

Garrett · 2:42

I don't think this guy farts without it being sponsored.

36:45

The music on this album is as important as the music playing in the grocery store as you walk through the meat aisle.

1:19:11

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.