The moments
- Tim hates everything on this album, not everything Metallica
- A bunch of middle-aged dudes, wildly insecure
- A date on the calendar three years before they wrote a word
- Dave Mustaine gets kicked out
- Dr. Towel writes the band a mission statement
- A hair tip for Kirk Hammett
- Bob Rock, and that haircut
- Album title options: Satanic Cuckoo Clock
- The parents locked in a room to make a metal album
- Charity bucket drums sound better than Lars's kit
- Garrett's favorite song, and why
- A two and a half minute song, three times
- Garrett's old notebook, covered in blood
- The lowest rated album we've ever done
Said on the show
Garrett, I absolutely hated everything on this album.
Tim · 0:43
To me, this album is what would have happened if we all had that friend whose parents fought all the time and then eventually got a divorce.
24:14
Every note of this feels begrudging.
24:14
This one wasn't even fun. I just hate it.
Garrett · 1:09:24
Running bits
Tim's a suckerStarted here
It goes back to Tim's mom calling him a sucker when he was nine. Listeners have been putting it in reviews since 2018.
Garrett's high school poetrysince #1 · 2018
Any lyric bad enough gets compared to the sad boy poems Garrett wrote at 16.
Where it started#1 · Korn - Follow the LeaderJan 22, 2018 · at 15:05
Would Lena Dunham approve?since #6 · 2018
Our moral compass. Before we judge a lyric, we check what Lena Dunham would think.
Where it started#6 · Justin Bieber - PurposeFeb 26, 2018 · at 22:53
Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.
