WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #19

Metallica - St Anger

#19 · May 29, 2018 · 1h 10m

Metallica - St Anger

We spent the week with St. Anger, Metallica's 2003 album, made with a producer who co-wrote it, a hired therapist, a group mission statement, and a release date set three years in advance. The documentary is as good as the album is bad. The drums ring the whole time, the songs are three short songs stuck together, and neither of us had any fun.

Did you hate it?

Metallica - St Anger

The moments

  1. Tim hates everything on this album, not everything Metallica
  2. A bunch of middle-aged dudes, wildly insecure
  3. A date on the calendar three years before they wrote a word
  4. Dave Mustaine gets kicked out
  5. Dr. Towel writes the band a mission statement
  6. A hair tip for Kirk Hammett
  7. Bob Rock, and that haircut
  8. Album title options: Satanic Cuckoo Clock
  9. The parents locked in a room to make a metal album
  10. Charity bucket drums sound better than Lars's kit
  11. Garrett's favorite song, and why
  12. A two and a half minute song, three times
  13. Garrett's old notebook, covered in blood
  14. The lowest rated album we've ever done

Said on the show

Garrett, I absolutely hated everything on this album.

Tim · 0:43

To me, this album is what would have happened if we all had that friend whose parents fought all the time and then eventually got a divorce.

24:14

Every note of this feels begrudging.

24:14

This one wasn't even fun. I just hate it.

Garrett · 1:09:24

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.