The moments
- God told them to make money, not Christian music
- Band names for our emo duo: Bottomless Soup
- Cable Car is an anagram, apparently
- Losing the Grammy to My Humps
- The Scrubs episode where the organs have rabies
- Funneling rabid badgers into your house
- Is perfection an orgasm?
- Jesus or the Flash in a foot race
- We might be the same person
- The downstairs hug
- A handwritten letter, read while Garrett watched
- Garrett reads his high school poem, Desolate
- A girlfriend made of straw
- Derek Jeter loves this album, per Brad
Said on the show
If you were to take all love songs ever written, strip them of any unique features, and then take the average of all of those, this might be what you get.
24:13
Tim, I would like to help you to bring a small claim suit against members of the fray and represent you as your personal attorney.
Garrett · 1:00:54
If they're not going to have anything to say, it's our responsibility to assign these songs meaning.
22:39
Track 12 is about tracks 1 through 11.
1:11:01
Running bits
Garrett's high school poetrysince #1 · 2018
Any lyric bad enough gets compared to the sad boy poems Garrett wrote at 16.
Where it started#1 · Korn - Follow the LeaderJan 22, 2018 · at 15:05
The weekly 9-11 referencesince #5 · 2018
There is a 9-11 reference in more episodes than you would think. Since mid-2021 we call it out when it lands: your weekly 9-11 reference.
Where it started#5 · Smash Mouth - Astro LoungeFeb 19, 2018 · at 4:11
Would Lena Dunham approve?since #6 · 2018
Our moral compass. Before we judge a lyric, we check what Lena Dunham would think.
Where it started#6 · Justin Bieber - PurposeFeb 26, 2018 · at 22:53
Tim's a suckersince #19 · 2018
It goes back to Tim's mom calling him a sucker when he was nine. Listeners have been putting it in reviews since 2018.
Where it started#19 · Metallica - St AngerMay 29, 2018 · at 47:48
Texas Toastsince #24 · 2018
Our rap group, named in a 2018 band name brainstorm. Tim is the Stallion, Garrett is Gare Bear, and practices are mandatory.
Where it started#24 · Florida Georgia Line - Here's to the Good Times (DELUXE EDITION)Jul 3, 2018 · at 17:48
Tim Antwoordsince #25 · 2018
Tim looks like he belongs in Die Antwoord. Listeners still want Tim Antwoord.
Where it started#25 · Nicki Minaj - Pink FridayJul 10, 2018 · at 1:12:25
Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.
