WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / PRE #129

Will Smith - Pretty Girls

PRE #129 · Jul 8, 2025 · 1h 21m

Will Smith - Pretty Girls

A lot of you demanded Will Smith's brand new 2025 single Pretty Girls, and we didn't let it go stale on the vine. Tim hated it at the top; Garrett got there before the first segment was over, a show first. By the end it's our Smash Mouth All Star: we hate it, and it brought us a lot of joy.

Did you hate it?

Will Smith - Pretty Girls

The moments

  1. Tim turns 40 and makes butterscotch with Garrett's scotch
  2. Garrett gets there in record time
  3. Will Smith's tiny vial of glitter
  4. The IRS director wears Wesley Snipes' Blade gear
  5. Will Smith's theme song for The Matrix
  6. Every movie he turned down
  7. It's better at 1.25 speed
  8. Two fives make a dime
  9. The jet ski alibi
  10. Is he into giant women?
  11. Dancing on the therapist's coffee table
  12. Tim's very specific code about Tipper Gore
  13. LeAnn Rimes has Garrett's dentist
  14. The world's largest collection of Plymouth Prowlers

Said on the show

I am enraged. I am embarrassed on behalf of Mr. Smith and on behalf of myself.

Tim · 3:09

Garrett, this feels like a song that would have been used in a movie like Demolition Man as shorthand for future music is terrible.

Tim · 23:46

I'm leaning into hate. It's Smash Mouth's All Star, if you will.

Tim · 54:40

I think I hate it, but it's brought me a lot of joy.

Garrett · 55:27

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.