WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / PRE #135

Muse - You Make Me Feel Like It's Halloween

PRE #135 · Oct 28, 2025 · 1h 15m

Muse - You Make Me Feel Like It's Halloween

We closed out the October scare-tacular with the much requested Muse single You Make Me Feel Like It's Halloween, from 2022's Will of the People. We read it as either Michael Myers play gone wrong or a song about lockdowns, and the music video gave us the tech ninjas. It's fine, it's Halloween-y, it's very safe, and neither of us hates it.

Did you hate it?

Muse - You Make Me Feel Like It's Halloween

The moments

  1. Tim's data-driven prevenge
  2. Why we stopped the prank wars
  3. Matt Bellamy's dad beat the Beatles to number one
  4. Tim spells out Teignmouth
  5. Our official stance on smashing instruments
  6. Should it be Febu-scary?
  7. Michael Myers play
  8. The time Garrett sneezed in Tim's mouth
  9. The tech ninjas
  10. If Garrett made a planet: sexy centaurs
  11. A bake-off with Nightmare on My Street
  12. Can a human mouth fit a horse tooth?
  13. Save an intern, pick an album
  14. The gerrymandered bylaws

Said on the show

This should be way more fun than it is. And it's just not.

Tim · 3:37

Fails to deliver on a fantastic premise. At times, it reaches high highs with incredible low lows.

Garrett · 4:15

Listeners, if you've got blood coming out of any of your holes, that's usually a pretty good sign to go to the doctor.

14:56

I earnestly hate that you extend Spooktober into other months.

Garrett · 1:11:55

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.