The moments
- A boilermaker made of butterscotch schnapps
- Fortifying the couch bed with eBay Bibles
- The bassist formerly known as Timi Grabber
- King Diamond's haunted apartment has a stuck door
- King Diamond sings like a very high Mickey Mouse
- The lyrics, read as Truman Capote
- Garrett naps three and a half hours to it
- Summoned by Grandma mid-chat with Einstein
- Tim's recurring dream where night is going blind
- Constipated Yoda
- The band forgot King Diamond's birthday
- Hell is probably a Sandals resort
- Three ghosts for dinner
- Waterboarded with Kool-Aid
Said on the show
I have fortified our couch bed, living room, kitchen areas with as many Bibles as I could buy on eBay.
Tim · 3:33
Beating Garrett in backgammon would be incredibly difficult, but your life will not improve in any meaningful way if you spent years training to beat him.
Tim · 24:33
I am shocked, and I guess not surprised, but amused to learn that satanic music and Christian music are equally lame.
Tim · 1:26:11
It sounds like somebody bought the karaoke versions of this and just did some sort of crazy voice on top of it.
Garrett · 1:27:18
Running bits
Moloch, the owl godsince #33 · 2018
Tim worships many gods. Mostly Jesus, a little Ra, and let us not forget Moloch.
Where it started#33 · Britney Spears - In the ZoneSep 4, 2018 · at 45:24
The couch bedssince #41 · 2018
We sleep on couch beds at the office. Do not sit on Tim's couch bed.
Where it started#41 · My Chemical Romance - The Black ParadeOct 30, 2018 · at 45:51
The ApologetiX coversince #95 · 2020
A Christian parody band with 35 albums of cleaned up covers. If they covered the song, we play it.
Where it started#95 · Good Charlotte - The Young and the HopelessJun 16, 2020 · at 39:09
La Fin. Shia LaBeouf.since #152 · 2022
How Tim closes out the history segment.
Where it started#152 · Hootie & the Blowfish - Cracked Rear ViewMay 31, 2022 · at 16:20
Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.