WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #227

KISS - Music from The Elder

#227 · Jun 10, 2025 · 1h 38m

KISS - Music from The Elder

We spent a week with Music from The Elder, the 1981 concept album where KISS hired the producer of The Wall to make their own The Wall and ended up with a Renaissance fair about a boy being trained by a council of elders for a movie that was never made. Tim calls it both subjectively and objectively terrible, and also kind of adorable. Neither of us can hate it, any more than you could hate a middle school play.

Did you hate it?

KISS - Music from The Elder

The moments

  1. Tim unrolls an Interpol agent from a carpet
  2. The Strawberry, a ruthless killer
  3. Bowie's musical about the first 15 minutes of Star Wars
  4. I Was Made for Lovin' You, right above Garrett's head
  5. Tim's filibuster for all four solo albums
  6. The drummer who wanted to be the Hawk, not Big Bird
  7. Did The Matrix steal this plot?
  8. The falsetto that sent us to Wikipedia
  9. Morpheus is the boy: a Looper situation
  10. Texas Toast's new names: the Stallion and the Bear
  11. Beware the dark half
  12. A nude Will Ferrell bursts out of the boy
  13. Medieval Times for Tim's birthday, again
  14. Escape from the island on a corpse boat

Said on the show

I think it is both subjectively and objectively terrible. But I think we're going to say this word quite a bit this week. It's kind of adorable.

Tim · 5:08

This would be like, I don't know, hating a middle school play. Like, they tried real hard. Clearly this isn't their forte.

Garrett · 5:49

Listen, we have a rigorous filibuster process here on the show when somebody disagrees with a pick.

Garrett · 18:35

I won't. I love dinner theater.

Tim · 1:15:18

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.