WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / PRE #154

Sufjan Stevens - John Wayne Gacy Jr

PRE #154 · Nov 10, 2026 · 1h 32m

Sufjan Stevens - John Wayne Gacy Jr

Tim picked Sufjan Stevens' John Wayne Gacy Jr from Illinois to close out a Scaretacular that ran into November. It's a whisper-quiet piano ballad about a serial killer, and the last lines turn it into something like a sermon, which we have thoughts on. Neither of us hates it, and Garrett might listen to it more now.

Did you hate it?

Sufjan Stevens - John Wayne Gacy Jr

The moments

  1. A firm policy on listener nudes
  2. Play us on YouTube on mute, like Daredevil
  3. The Scaretacular spills into November
  4. The worst phone call a best friend ever got
  5. He made everyone call him the Colonel
  6. A mini golf course in prison
  7. Go Wildcats, three schools running
  8. Corey Feldman, our musical peer
  9. A 58-song Christmas album
  10. That smell is your garbage pot roast, dear
  11. Yogi's dog sense flags a house
  12. Jimmy Carter lusts after peanuts
  13. A YouTube comment on human meat and Iowa
  14. The Barone Report, an Everybody Loves Raymond podcast

Said on the show

That's hard for us because we are, and this is true, completely illegitimate as a show.

Garrett · 2:38

There is oodles of garbage. I think that's the official term.

Tim · 6:50

Huge distinction between sinner and serial killer.

55:20

Make a second friend.

1:03:46

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.