WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #254

Alice Cooper - Welcome to My Nightmare

#254 · Nov 3, 2026 · 1h 36m

Alice Cooper - Welcome to My Nightmare

For our annual Dia de los Muertos episode, we spent a week with Welcome to My Nightmare, Alice Cooper's 1975 solo debut and a concept album about a boy named Steven that keeps forgetting it's a concept album. It's one third Broadway, one third jazz and one third rock and roll, with Vincent Price giving a tour of a bug museum. Neither of us got there, but one of us got real close.

Did you hate it?

Alice Cooper - Welcome to My Nightmare

The moments

  1. Tim's adventures held hostage until you subscribe
  2. The Han Solo of the show? At best, Lobot
  3. Garrett knows Alice Cooper's wieners better than his music
  4. A cop saved by his belt buckle
  5. Tim loves Halloween, as long as it's not too scary
  6. The chicken incident
  7. Two cases of 1970s Budweiser a day
  8. Addiction cured with Jesus and golf
  9. Vincent Price's tour of the bug museum
  10. Our new circle cult and the monocle of the devil
  11. Training for the drugs world record
  12. Keeping a corpse fresh until you're 97
  13. Steven, I thought you were dead
  14. Stuck on track two of the eight track for two hours

Said on the show

I have the exact same three percentages in the opposite order. And statistically, that does mean, in fact, that I do hate this.

Garrett · 3:45

I would know an Alice Cooper wiener before I would know an Alice Cooper album.

Garrett · 6:01

I love it as long as it's not too scary.

Tim · 9:31

It's an album that manages to achieve pleasing absolutely nobody.

1:31:29

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.