WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / PRE #150

Barry Manilow - I Write the Songs

PRE #150 · Aug 25, 2026 · 1h 28m

Barry Manilow - I Write the Songs

Tim saw Barry Manilow close out the Houston rodeo in 2001 and thought it sucked back then, so this was always going to be rough. We dug into the 1975 number one that Bruce Johnston wrote, decided it's sung by either an ancient music god or an Apocalypse-style mutant, and found a whole corner of the internet that thinks it's Satan talking. We both hated it by the end.

Did you hate it?

Barry Manilow - I Write the Songs

The moments

  1. Tim's blanket retraction for the 98 Degrees episode
  2. Tim saw Barry close out the Houston rodeo at 15
  3. Smuggling Jack Daniels in leaky Ziploc bags
  4. Barry wrote the State Farm jingle for $500
  5. A judge sued Barry for rocking too hard
  6. Manilow as a crowd dispersal weapon
  7. Admit the small lie to hide the big lie
  8. An Apocalypse-style mutant who conquers with music
  9. Swifties as a human shield
  10. The Sunday Mandy block
  11. The internet thinks Satan wrote this song
  12. The Full House subreddit weighs in on Satan
  13. A pet scorpion named after the Thong Song guy
  14. William Shatner's rider: Faygo, a DeLorean, puppies

Said on the show

I remember thinking to my 15-year-old self, God, this sucks. What a dickhead. And I still kind of feel that way.

Tim · 6:18

He's the Frank Sinatra for the elderly woman who Frank Sinatra was just a little bit too much for.

35:32

I'm in no way insulting your reporting skills. I think you've gone a bit far afield of the intention of the segment and that's okay.

Garrett · 59:18

If I'm checking to see how much is left in a four minute song, you fucked up.

Garrett · 1:01:22

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.