The moments
- Tim's blanket retraction for the 98 Degrees episode
- Tim saw Barry close out the Houston rodeo at 15
- Smuggling Jack Daniels in leaky Ziploc bags
- Barry wrote the State Farm jingle for $500
- A judge sued Barry for rocking too hard
- Manilow as a crowd dispersal weapon
- Admit the small lie to hide the big lie
- An Apocalypse-style mutant who conquers with music
- Swifties as a human shield
- The Sunday Mandy block
- The internet thinks Satan wrote this song
- The Full House subreddit weighs in on Satan
- A pet scorpion named after the Thong Song guy
- William Shatner's rider: Faygo, a DeLorean, puppies
Said on the show
I remember thinking to my 15-year-old self, God, this sucks. What a dickhead. And I still kind of feel that way.
Tim · 6:18
He's the Frank Sinatra for the elderly woman who Frank Sinatra was just a little bit too much for.
35:32
I'm in no way insulting your reporting skills. I think you've gone a bit far afield of the intention of the segment and that's okay.
Garrett · 59:18
If I'm checking to see how much is left in a four minute song, you fucked up.
Garrett · 1:01:22
Running bits
The weekly 9-11 referencesince #5 · 2018
There is a 9-11 reference in more episodes than you would think. Since mid-2021 we call it out when it lands: your weekly 9-11 reference.
Where it started#5 · Smash Mouth - Astro LoungeFeb 19, 2018 · at 4:11
Would Lena Dunham approve?since #6 · 2018
Our moral compass. Before we judge a lyric, we check what Lena Dunham would think.
Where it started#6 · Justin Bieber - PurposeFeb 26, 2018 · at 22:53
Tim's a suckersince #19 · 2018
It goes back to Tim's mom calling him a sucker when he was nine. Listeners have been putting it in reviews since 2018.
Where it started#19 · Metallica - St AngerMay 29, 2018 · at 47:48
Spooktember and Sexy Springsince #79 · 2019
Our calendar: the spooky months (several), Sexy Spring, Spicy Summer, and Sublime Summer.
Where it started#79 · Billie Eilish - When We All Fall Asleep, Where Do We Go?Nov 12, 2019 · at 3:38
The ApologetiX coversince #95 · 2020
A Christian parody band with 35 albums of cleaned up covers. If they covered the song, we play it.
Where it started#95 · Good Charlotte - The Young and the HopelessJun 16, 2020 · at 39:09
CBS on Paramount+since PRE #44 · 2021
It started with an official apology to this episode's sponsors, CBS and Paramount+. Now the lawyers and censors have notes.
Where it startedPRE #44 · Cardi B ft Megan Thee Stallion - WAPFeb 23, 2021 · at 20:20
Go Wildcatssince PRE #95 · 2023
Every high school and college in an artist's history gets a Go Wildcats, whatever the mascot.
Where it startedPRE #95 · Harvey Danger - Flagpole SittaSep 26, 2023 · at 9:54
Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.