WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #84

Cake - Fashion Nugget

#84 · Jan 14, 2020 · 1h 35m

Cake - Fashion Nugget

You requested Cake's Fashion Nugget more than any other Cake album, and we came in expecting not to hate it. Garrett built a whole story out of it, one ongoing character who keeps getting rejected, with a bakery dream, a trunk and a drug loaf. Three covers beat the originals, and by track six we both got there.

Did you hate it?

Cake - Fashion Nugget

The moments

  1. The band name means something that cakes onto your shoe
  2. Tim's calendar archive goes back to 1987
  3. The hipster band that rebelled against grunge
  4. Anyone may throw a D battery at the stage
  5. The top 10 albums of 1996
  6. Frank Sinatra: a smart sounding opener, maybe
  7. The Distance is about a celebrity baker
  8. Friend Is a Four Letter Word, as annotated online
  9. Cake: The Musical
  10. Tim's seduction seminar and its PowerPoint
  11. Daria and the man who can't use his arms
  12. Stick Shifts, Safety Belts, and trunk sex
  13. She'll come back to me, said every ex's VCR
  14. Drug loaf

Said on the show

I was ready to like Cake.

Garrett · 24:04

This band is what this show could be if we took ourselves even remotely seriously.

Tim · 14:12

The monotone way that this is sung, it's not ironic. It just loses any meaning.

Tim · 53:09

This is the first time we can say in a while, the artist did all the heavy lifting. Our sheer effort to slog our way through this relentlessly repetitive album.

1:31:55

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.