The moments
- Garrett hates it way more than he thought he would
- How the band got its name: a walk through a puddle of mud
- A first album in 1997, a breakup in 1999
- Come Clean arrives, and so does the wrestling theme
- A set list of covers
- On numerous songs, they're clearly trying to be Nirvana
- A song about enjoying pain and a safe word
- Tim asks Garrett to look him in the eyes
- Looking back at a childhood that wasn't too bad
- She Hates Me, and the very obvious Nirvana ripoff
- The DJ in hell plays only the two worst songs
- Does Jesus sleep? And do the others in heaven?
- Peaked at No. 9, triple platinum
- Both of us hate it
Said on the show
You know what is a shock to me, Tim? How much I hate it. I hate it way more than I thought I would.
Garrett · 1:04
I don't care. I hate this song. I hate this album.
Garrett · 1:09:16
This is utter shit.
1:22:05
Running bits
Would Lena Dunham approve?since #6 · 2018
Our moral compass. Before we judge a lyric, we check what Lena Dunham would think.
Where it started#6 · Justin Bieber - PurposeFeb 26, 2018 · at 22:53
Tim's a suckersince #19 · 2018
It goes back to Tim's mom calling him a sucker when he was nine. Listeners have been putting it in reviews since 2018.
Where it started#19 · Metallica - St AngerMay 29, 2018 · at 47:48
Texas Toastsince #24 · 2018
Our rap group, named in a 2018 band name brainstorm. Tim is the Stallion, Garrett is Gare Bear, and practices are mandatory.
Where it started#24 · Florida Georgia Line - Here's to the Good Times (DELUXE EDITION)Jul 3, 2018 · at 17:48
Tim Antwoordsince #25 · 2018
Tim looks like he belongs in Die Antwoord. Listeners still want Tim Antwoord.
Where it started#25 · Nicki Minaj - Pink FridayJul 10, 2018 · at 1:12:25
The couch bedssince #41 · 2018
We sleep on couch beds at the office. Do not sit on Tim's couch bed.
Where it started#41 · My Chemical Romance - The Black ParadeOct 30, 2018 · at 45:51
Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.