WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #52

Puddle of Mudd - Come Clean

#52 · Jan 15, 2019 · 1h 28m

Puddle of Mudd - Come Clean

A lot of you asked for Puddle of Mudd, so we spent a week with Come Clean, the 2001 album that came after the grunge era had already ended. It borrows heavily from Nirvana, has a surprising amount to say about dominatrices and heaven, and gets whiny in the places that need to be fun. We both hate it, and Garrett hated it way more than he expected.

Did you hate it?

Puddle of Mudd - Come Clean

The moments

  1. Garrett hates it way more than he thought he would
  2. How the band got its name: a walk through a puddle of mud
  3. A first album in 1997, a breakup in 1999
  4. Come Clean arrives, and so does the wrestling theme
  5. A set list of covers
  6. On numerous songs, they're clearly trying to be Nirvana
  7. A song about enjoying pain and a safe word
  8. Tim asks Garrett to look him in the eyes
  9. Looking back at a childhood that wasn't too bad
  10. She Hates Me, and the very obvious Nirvana ripoff
  11. The DJ in hell plays only the two worst songs
  12. Does Jesus sleep? And do the others in heaven?
  13. Peaked at No. 9, triple platinum
  14. Both of us hate it

Said on the show

You know what is a shock to me, Tim? How much I hate it. I hate it way more than I thought I would.

Garrett · 1:04

I don't care. I hate this song. I hate this album.

Garrett · 1:09:16

This is utter shit.

1:22:05

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.