WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #51

#51 · Jan 8, 2019 · 56m

Mailbag!

Our first mailbag episode is all you: emails, favorite reviews, social media posts, songs people wrote about us, and a voicemail we're still not sure how we got. Along the way Tim tells the story of how not to build your own fireworks, Garrett and Tim explain how to tell their voices apart, and Tim's a Sucker reaches its peak. It's a thank you for the weirdest, most inside jokes we get.

Did you hate it?

Mailbag!

The moments

  1. Today we read our favorite mailbag and reviews
  2. A listener pitches a concept album about Elmo
  3. How to tell Tim and Garrett apart
  4. Throwing drinks at a car playing The Fray
  5. How hard can it be to build your own fireworks?
  6. PVC pipe, black powder, gasoline and toilet paper
  7. The chubby lad who lit the fuses
  8. A fan theory: Tim is a vampire who loves the unloved
  9. A five-star review that just says Tim's a Sucker
  10. A review where Tim's a Sucker is a short story
  11. A five-star review of our house as a restaurant
  12. The Ballad of Tim and Garrett
  13. A voicemail from fellow podcasters
  14. Tim's arms wide open

Said on the show

If there's one voice that seems to exude rugged masculinity, assume that's Garrett.

9:12

We're not a restaurant. I don't believe we are a restaurant.

33:55

Okay, I didn't even know we had a landline here at the Why I Hate This Album Podcast World Headquarters.

50:17

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.