WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #130

Weezer - Pinkerton

#130 · Aug 17, 2021 · 1h 57m

Weezer - Pinkerton

Weezer fans hold up Pinkerton, the 1996 follow up to the Blue Album, as the one perfect record, and we both remembered liking it. Then we read the lyrics alongside the Madame Butterfly story it's named for, plus a song about a fan letter from Japan, and the whole thing turned sinister. Tim hates it from the top, and Garrett holds out for nearly two hours before he gives in.

Did you hate it?

Weezer - Pinkerton

The moments

  1. Tim has lost three weeks and woke up in the crawl space
  2. Tim's history is word for word the same as last time
  3. The main Weez, a rare compliment
  4. His little brother was named Leaves
  5. The crowdfunding campaign to pay Weezer to break up
  6. Four albums, one for each season. Fuck your face, Rivers.
  7. The Pinkerton detective agency sued over the album title
  8. Jen, Lynn, Catherine and Denise: a very specific list
  9. A tattoo and two pet snakes
  10. Across the Sea is where we stop caring about the music
  11. Tim's foot transplant business plan
  12. Reading her diary for Green Day entries
  13. The butterfly story, allegedly stolen from Insane Clown Posse
  14. Give in to the hate, Garrett

Said on the show

This is the ace in the hole. If you say you don't like Weezer, they say, yeah, maybe you don't like their later output, but you have to at least admit Pinkerton is great.

Tim · 3:38

Fuck your face, Rivers. It kind of does it.

Garrett · 30:18

That's like singing about how great the song you just wrote is in that song you're singing.

1:24:06

I can't co-sign this. No matter how much I enjoy two songs.

Garrett · 1:51:39

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.