WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / PRE #64

Warrant - Cherry Pie

PRE #64 · Feb 15, 2022 · 1h 12m

Warrant - Cherry Pie

We went after dark for Cherry Pie, the 1990 Warrant song that showed up late to the hair metal party and was written in about 15 minutes on a pizza box to keep the label happy. It's terrible, it's kind of glorious, and the music video has a smile we'll never unsee. Neither of us hates it.

Did you hate it?

Warrant - Cherry Pie

The moments

  1. Tom Brady has been trolling Tim all week
  2. Tim's sign: Tom Brady, I love you, plus his phone number
  3. Tim knows the song but has never heard it. Inception?
  4. It's just Pour Some Sugar on Me, lightly changed
  5. The singer's parents named him John Kennedy Oswald
  6. Garrett bought Tim the original pizza box. There's cheese on it.
  7. The danger of thinking about baseball
  8. Batter, beaters and a rotary device
  9. I'm a trained professional. He's a gigolo.
  10. Warrant plays forever in Pennywise's deadlights
  11. Whipped cream goes straight in your mouth, plus a little gas
  12. The 10 mile wide smile that haunts our nightmares
  13. Garrett denies a habit of propofoling Tim
  14. Jeremy Renner's Rennervations

Said on the show

This is terrible, but it's also kind of glorious.

Tim · 5:41

It's a visual representation of my failure.

Garrett · 19:19

They spent four to eight times more time getting ready each day than they did writing the song.

35:25

Nobody presented nearly enough evidence to get there.

Garrett · 48:29

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.