WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / PRE #109

Paula Cole - Where Have All the Cowboys Gone?

PRE #109 · Jul 9, 2024 · 1h 24m

Paula Cole - Where Have All the Cowboys Gone?

We spent a week with Paula Cole's Where Have All the Cowboys Gone?, the 90s hit she later said was satire. Garrett knew every word from screaming it at his sister in a Mercury Topaz; Tim came in very, very close to hating it and also read a Catholic book on manliness with the same title. Neither of us got there, and we left with a new shirt: Everyone needs a cowboy, Garrett.

Did you hate it?

Paula Cole - Where Have All the Cowboys Gone?

The moments

  1. Tim's week with Bear Woznick's 12 Rules for Manliness
  2. A Catholic men's group in a church basement
  3. Tim for sainthood. Downside: you're dead
  4. Vermin Supreme and a free pony for every American
  5. A voicemail from Peter Gabriel
  6. James Van Der Beek, moral paragon of the show
  7. It takes exactly $75,000 to make an album
  8. It's basically a lady Train situation
  9. Alternate reading: she's been abducted
  10. Tim really, really hates John Wayne
  11. Everyone needs a cowboy, comma, Garrett
  12. The lady being a bird at Widespread Panic
  13. Toys in mason jars hanging from trees
  14. Amazon reviews for the wrong book

Said on the show

I think, tragically, Garrett, I think that this song thinks it's important.

Tim · 21:40

Everyone needs a cowboy, Garrett. Come on.

Tim · 37:21

If you find cracks or weaknesses in the foundation of your relationship, shore them up with a baby.

39:27

Gotta tell you, though, if this truly is irony, you have failed as a songwriter.

34:28

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.