WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #208

#208 · Jul 23, 2024 · 1h 46m

Styx - Greatest Hits

We wanted to do a Styx album but only knew the hits, so we spent a week with their 1995 Greatest Hits, all 16 songs, and it turns out we knew four. Tim was enraged that one in four of their greatest hits is a hit; Garrett likes Styx and didn't hate it at the top. Tim singing Lady almost turned him, but by the end we hated it together.

Did you hate it?

Styx - Greatest Hits

The moments

  1. Garrett gets wicker-manned in Wales
  2. Just dip the whole baby in the River Styx
  3. The power of seven: July 7, 1977
  4. A Desert Shield remix, for some reason
  5. Lady is a cult hymn
  6. Tim's rate for giant lady fan fiction
  7. A reverse time machine for the worst of times
  8. The time we robbed a Taco Cabana out of boredom
  9. If you like Babe, you're an idiot
  10. Music designed to be actively erection reducing
  11. Garrett left Heaven's Gate over the balls thing
  12. Blue Collar Man, the trade school infomercial
  13. Kilroy escapes inside a Roboto
  14. A man who proposed with Lady on a boombox

Said on the show

This is a band that can be excellent for minutes on end and yet chooses to turn in some of the worst songs we have heard in possibly years, and on their Greatest Hits album.

Tim · 3:43

These guys don't fuck. They're flaccid.

28:39

This is their only number one single because most people, and this is true, are idiots.

Tim · 57:17

Somehow, this band does the opposite. Like, the whole is somehow less than the sum of its parts.

29:42

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.