WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / BONUS

Bobby Pickett - Monster Mash

BONUS · Oct 31, 2018 · 19m

Bobby Pickett - Monster Mash

We couldn't end the October scare-a-thon without paying tribute to the man who started it all: Bobby Boris Pickett and his 1962 novelty classic Monster Mash. Tim suggested it to torture Garrett, who has long claimed to hate it, and then Garrett watched a 1962 performance and gained an appreciation for the mash. Neither of us hates it, and we are sad about that.

Did you hate it?

Bobby Pickett - Monster Mash

The moments

  1. The final installment of our 2018 Halloween Spooktacular
  2. Garrett said he hated this, three times
  3. The 1962 talk show performance that changed everything
  4. Does he kind of have Tourette's? No, and we're sorry.
  5. Rejected by every major label until Gary Paxton
  6. Number three in Britain in 1973
  7. The monster solves it by rapping
  8. Two fun facts from the lab
  9. Every song fits better to the Monster Mash music
  10. 3,481 songs analyzed, 100 percent success rate
  11. It can't be vampires, they're already there
  12. A listener's review: set as my ringtone
  13. Do you hate this? Absolutely not.
  14. When 1962 finally arrives in North Korea

Said on the show

It's a pretty great song. I think we can agree on that up front.

Tim · 1:08

I gained an appreciation for the mash, dude.

Garrett · 1:30

It might be the gold standard for songwriting in modern America.

9:39

I love it. You love it. America loves it.

17:04

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.