The moments
- Tim doesn't hate it. Not yet
- A tentative hate, in case Jack is listening
- Seeing Jack White in New York, San Francisco and everywhere in between
- Icky Thump, the most complex White Stripes album
- At best, a mixtape
- Connected by love
- Jack White might be starting a cult
- A potty, and the thing Garrett hates most
- A bank robbery with nowhere to go
- Tim's mom's hot take that sums up the album
- Garrett names the guy in the mineshaft Lyle
- Spoken word, then robots, then Peter Frampton
- The second best song on the album is from 1894
- Both of us hate it, and blame Jack
Said on the show
I don't like it, but I can't say I hate it.
Tim · 1:30
I tentatively hate it.
Garrett · 2:12
This is, at best, to use the parlance of our time, a mixtape. Not good enough to be released as an album.
22:11
Jack, you're better than this.
1:21:05
Running bits
Would Lena Dunham approve?since #6 · 2018
Our moral compass. Before we judge a lyric, we check what Lena Dunham would think.
Where it started#6 · Justin Bieber - PurposeFeb 26, 2018 · at 22:53
Tim's a suckersince #19 · 2018
It goes back to Tim's mom calling him a sucker when he was nine. Listeners have been putting it in reviews since 2018.
Where it started#19 · Metallica - St AngerMay 29, 2018 · at 47:48
Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.
