WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #253

Luke Bryan - Signs

#253 · Oct 13, 2026 · 1h 47m

Luke Bryan - Signs

We kicked off Spooky Season with Luke Bryan's brand new ninth album, Signs, and we're both so glad we did the whole album and not just a single. It goes from banal to Christmas Shoes level crazy and right back again, with a murder, a beer tree and a song sung by a handgun along the way. Garrett despised it from the top, Tim hated it by the end, and we both kind of loved it.

Did you hate it?

Luke Bryan - Signs

The moments

  1. Tim fact-checks last week's tears and boners email
  2. Thomas Luther Bryan, so why Luke?
  3. Country music Dave and Buster's
  4. Build Me a Daddy, with all the parts
  5. Nine album covers, one Dutch angle
  6. A hit song written from four emojis
  7. Finders Keepers is an organ harvesting grift
  8. Word on the Street is about a murder
  9. A monkey paw love song
  10. The beer tree villain origin story
  11. A money grubbing corn kink succubus
  12. Killer, the secret life of pistols
  13. Disney Pixar presents: Guns
  14. What is he burying in that field?

Said on the show

This thing goes from stupid and banal to just shy of Christmas Shoes level crazy, and then right back again as if nothing had happened.

Tim · 4:42

This song is Christmas Shoes level of insane. This is a song sung from the perspective of a handgun.

Tim · 1:20:34

This is conceptually no better than if this song was called Video Game Masturbate Pot Fart.

54:23

It's for people that don't like music, but hate silence.

1:41:02

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.