WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #252

Modest Mouse - The Golden Casket

#252 · Sep 22, 2026 · 1h 37m

Modest Mouse - The Golden Casket

A truckload of you asked for Modest Mouse's The Golden Casket, so we spent a week with it. One of us has seen the band seven times and the other is mostly a Modest Mouse apologist, which turned out to be the problem. Neither of us got there, and we have some guidance for your future recommendations.

Did you hate it?

Modest Mouse - The Golden Casket

The moments

  1. Tim wakes up with a Die Antwoord makeover
  2. A school for extraordinarily gifted mutants
  3. Faking speaking in tongues with Mary Poppins
  4. Modest Mouse song titles we made up
  5. The credits list paper bags filled with wood
  6. A time loop that starts at birth
  7. Is wanting to hotwire a car universal?
  8. A witch who lures beach children into her oven
  9. A song that sounds like Vogue
  10. Are trolls real?
  11. Aliens on the doorstep mistaken for stork babies
  12. Peeping etiquette
  13. Tim's handwritten encyclopedia

Said on the show

What if you got trapped in a time loop that starts at birth?

Garrett · 47:12

I have done a lot of Wikipedia editing to get you to believe things.

Tim · 1:25:52

Wiccans in our audience, please do not curse us... I just said that to sound cool. I am very scared of you.

Tim · 11:07

It's not an admonishment. It's guidance for future recommendations.

Garrett · 1:33:12

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.