WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / PRE #83

David Crosby - Cowboy Movie

PRE #83 · Feb 14, 2023 · 1h 17m

David Crosby - Cowboy Movie

We spent a week with Cowboy Movie, from David Crosby's 1971 album If I Could Only Remember My Name, with the Grateful Dead jamming behind him for eight and a half minutes. It's a Western about his CSNY bandmates as outlaws that skips the train robbery and goes straight to the arguing over a woman. Neither of us hates it, mostly because it isn't really a song, and it's adorable for all the wrong reasons.

Did you hate it?

David Crosby - Cowboy Movie

The moments

  1. Tim diagnoses Garrett with scurvy
  2. Shanghaied onto a pirate ship
  3. Suggested by Tom B. Rady, not Tom Brady
  4. How Tim made Garrett hate Mr. Tambourine Man
  5. The Forrest Gump of music festivals
  6. Doing the math on $25 million in drugs
  7. Remember him as Lionel Hutz's AA sponsor
  8. Tim's cowboy fan fiction about us
  9. A cowboy song that skips the train robbery
  10. Neil Young communicates by bird call
  11. Our shorthand noises, revealed
  12. Do cowboys call their guns hardware?
  13. Nitroglycerin in the Old West
  14. The Robert Christgau game: rename David Crosby

Said on the show

I don't, I don't, but it is not a song, and if it were, it would not be a good song.

Tim · 3:37

It just doesn't follow enough of the basic conventions of music for me to recognize it as a song. Also, it's adorable and weird and funny, but not for any reasons he meant it to be.

3:57

He's the fucking Forrest Gump of music festivals.

16:02

It's written by a guy who thought he had a visual effects budget.

43:43

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.