WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #43

Carrie Underwood - Some Hearts

#43 · Nov 13, 2018 · 1h 29m

Carrie Underwood - Some Hearts

After a spooky October of nonsense, we ended up with Carrie Underwood's Some Hearts, an album Tim called room temperature skim milk compared to the last one. It's 14 tracks of generic country-pop with exactly one song that has a personality, which is the one where she wrecks a man's truck. Neither of us knew if we hated it, until we both got there at exactly the same moment.

Did you hate it?

Carrie Underwood - Some Hearts

The moments

  1. A bright shining light after a bleak October
  2. Tim pretended his name was Leo at Chuck E. Cheese
  3. Tim has heard one song 3,800 times
  4. A local admirer knows where you live
  5. What Garrett loves about Mustangs: nothing
  6. She's a respected songwriter, just not on this
  7. Quicksand videos, and a viewer's hot take
  8. In her defense, Jesus does save her
  9. Time marches forward and waits for no one
  10. The song where she wrecks his car
  11. Tracks 11 through 14 are all garbage
  12. 21 Walmarts in the greater Los Angeles area
  13. The $6,400 dinner
  14. The debut of The Ballad of Tim and Garrett

Said on the show

This is room temperature skim milk by comparison.

1:34

This whole thing plays it so safe. It refuses to have any personality. It refuses to do anything interesting.

1:22:42

I think this week we simultaneously got there together. At the same time, you getting me there while I get you there.

1:23:24

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.