WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #194

#194 · Jan 9, 2024 · 1h 39m

WIHTA - Greatest Hits - Best of Amazon Reviews - 2018 (Year 1): A Tim Solocast

Tim's first solocast is our first greatest hits album: the best Amazon reviews read on the show in 2018, our first year, played back from the old episodes. Garrett doesn't trust Tim alone after what happened with the moths, so it's really a duocast. There's no album to hate this week, just Bob Dylan writing reviews and a bonus track.

Did you hate it?

WIHTA - Greatest Hits - Best of Amazon Reviews - 2018 (Year 1): A Tim Solocast

The moments

  1. Mousetraps, bleach and no plumbing to keep Garrett out
  2. Tim can't get through the Smash Mouth review
  3. Not jealous of Bieber: he owns a 2011 Jeep Grand Cherokee
  4. An Eminem review written as a rap
  5. A rapper boy band, managed by Lou Pearlman's ghost
  6. Axl Rose, the Tarantino of rock
  7. In a field of dictators, Simple Plan is Stalin
  8. Scared straight by Sublime
  9. RIP Tank, demolition derby legend
  10. Sum 41 rocked his face clean off
  11. Chris Gaines on a San Francisco dance floor
  12. Bob Dylan is writing Amazon reviews
  13. A Jack White review that ends in a murder
  14. Garrett edits the clip Tim sent his mom

Said on the show

It's the moths. What you did with the moths has created a level of distrust in this professional relationship that makes me think you're not ready.

Garrett · 2:38

Bitch, I'm jealous of Justin Bieber.

19:05

Every night, army shells village, but Carrie Underwood keeps spirits high.

1:14:13

Well, that's the most unhinged thing we've ever featured on this show, Garrett.

Tim · 1:21:44

Running bits

All 34 running bits →

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.