WHY I HATE
THIS ALBUM

Episodes / #180

#180 · Jul 25, 2023 · 46m

Simon & Garfunkel / The Police

Tim's away finding the Dutch, so Garrett's on his own for part two of Band Breakups and Bitter Feuds, a two-for-one. First Simon & Garfunkel, from a sixth grade play to shoving each other at intermission in their sixties, then The Police, three men who loved the music and hated making it together. No album this week, just the fights.

Did you hate it?

Simon & Garfunkel / The Police

The moments

  1. The rabbit meets the Cheshire Cat in sixth grade
  2. Paul's secret solo contract
  3. Art's secret weapon: calling Paul little
  4. Sound of Silence takes off while Paul busks in England
  5. No Woodstock, because Art wouldn't fly back
  6. Eleven tracks, because neither would give up the twelfth
  7. Art Garfunkel, high school math teacher
  8. Harmonies written on a walking tour of Switzerland
  9. Artie, I'm wiping all your tapes
  10. Shoving at intermission, in their sixties
  11. Broken ribs, courtesy of the drummer
  12. Recording on separate floors in Montserrat
  13. Who gets paid for the Every Breath You Take guitar loop
  14. The snare war

Said on the show

I'd like to see a video of those two in a fistfight. I think my money's on Garfunkel.

Garrett · 21:27

This one's tough, because it requires me to defend Sting from time to time, and that's not something I care to do.

Garrett · 21:47

Who doesn't want to punch Sting a little bit, right?

Garrett · 27:34

Instead, all they're replaced with is the pretentious wailings of a man named Gordon, who insists that you call him Sting.

Garrett · 42:13

Running bits

Recurring bits from this episode go here: every one mentioned, and the episode where it started.

Why I Hate This Album is two friends, one bad album, every week since 2018. We take turns picking an album, listen to it for a week straight, then sit down and explain why we hate it.